Tar & Roses, the wood-fired restaurant at 602 Santa Monica Boulevard, set its final dine-in service for Saturday, October 24, after nearly 15 years. The closing date was reported by the Santa Monica Mirror. Three days earlier and about two miles south, chef-owner Brian Bornemann opened Bar Fortuna at 2917 Main Street in the former Vamos Vamos space, near his Crudo e Nudo, according to Eater LA.
Both stories came out in the same month as the RAND Corporation's report on Santa Monica, published October 1. RAND funded the study itself, and it compares Santa Monica with Beverly Hills, Culver City and West Hollywood. Most of the coverage focused on retail. For buyers deciding between these four cities, the more useful finding is in Chapter 5, the housing chapter. It shows a city that builds very little housing and builds it slowly.
What the downtown numbers measure
The retail findings are severe. The Santa Monica Daily Press summarized RAND's analysis of state tax data. In 2015 dollars, Santa Monica's taxable sales fell 32.8% between 2015 and 2025, from $3.24 billion to $2.18 billion. By the end of 2025, sales in Beverly Hills and West Hollywood were down 10% to 15% from 2015, and Culver City's were down 25%.
The losses fall unevenly across categories:
- Clothing and accessories: down 75%, or $327.7 million, the largest drop in both dollars and percentage
- Home furnishings: down 66.9%
- Gas stations: down 48%
- Restaurants and bars: down 23.8%, or $151.7 million
- Building materials and garden stores: the only category that grew
The authors say business closures, including large retailers leaving the Third Street Promenade and Santa Monica Place, are likely a major source of the decline. Building size shows the same concentration. As of August 2026, the Promenade's vacancy rate was 31%. In buildings over 30,000 square feet it was 47%, and in buildings under 10,000 square feet it was 12%. RAND estimates that at least 45% of the city's retail vacancy is tied to the Promenade and Santa Monica Place.
Downtown Santa Monica Inc. counts the Promenade differently. Speaking to the Los Angeles Times, chief executive Debbie Lee said the group counted 79% of Promenade stores as leased. She added that a property often stays on the market while a temporary tenant occupies it. The two figures use different measures, so the difference doesn't mean either one is wrong.
The city's response is aimed at downtown. In March 2026, the council approved an eight-point package. It includes a $3 million fund for recruiting businesses. It also removes the $1,000-per-seat wastewater fee for restaurants and expands the Entertainment Zone to Main Street and Montana Avenue. The city closed fiscal 2025-26 with an $8.95 million surplus, a year after declaring fiscal distress. One small-format opening came on October 2, when Gott's Roadside opened at Fourth Street and Wilshire Boulevard. The Daily Press called it a long-dormant corner.
Large downtown retail spaces explain much of the decline in sales tax. They tell a buyer little about the supply of homes, and the report addresses that separately.
The chapter on housing
RAND compared housing production per 10,000 residents from 2018 to 2025 across nine jurisdictions. Santa Monica had the second-lowest rate, above only Beverly Hills. From 2018 to 2024, it issued about 10 to 15 building permits per 10,000 residents a year. Culver City issued more per resident over that period, and Beverly Hills passed Santa Monica in 2021.
So the cities that beat Santa Monica on sales recovery also beat it on housing production, with one exception. Beverly Hills, the comparison city with the strongest retail rebound, built even fewer new homes.
A spike in housing applications in 2022 makes the low output stand out. Santa Monica had become subject to the state's builder's remedy, and between February and October 2022, developers filed 16 applications proposing a total of 4,260 units. In May 2023, the city reached a settlement that let those projects refile with expedited processing. After that, the number of applications dropped sharply. As of 2024, none of those units appeared in permit counts.
Six years, stage by stage
RAND measured how long housing projects take using the city's permit records. On average, a project takes 403 days to win entitlement and another 726 days to get a building permit. It takes 965 more days to reach final sign-off, usually a Certificate of Occupancy for multifamily buildings. The report puts the full process at more than six years, compared with 4.9 years for projects under the West Los Angeles Area Planning Commission. The three stage averages add up to 2,094 days, about 5.7 years, and the report does not explain the difference from its six-year figure.
Much of the extra time comes from the Coastal Zone:
| Phase in Santa Monica | Outside Coastal Zone | Inside Coastal Zone | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Application to entitlement approval | 396 days | 701 days | 77% longer inside |
| Entitlement to building permit | 958 days | 1,072 days | 12% longer inside |
| Building permit to Certificate of Occupancy | 1,121 days | 918 days | 18% shorter inside |
| Projects in sample | 233 | 32 |
RAND notes that longer timelines raise costs, because land and other predevelopment costs have to be financed for longer. They also expose projects to rising construction costs and to new regulations. The city is updating its Local Coastal Program. Once that program is fully certified, applicants can get local and coastal development permits directly from the city, which RAND says could shorten timelines.
These are historical averages, but they show how long the pipeline is. Adding the two later stages, a project that has just won entitlement averages 1,691 days, more than four and a half years, before anyone can move in. RAND's six-year figure counts from the original application.
The homes already approved
The Daily Press coverage of the housing chapter found 3,296 market-rate units and 878 affordable units with approvals but no building permits. For buyers, the question is how many of those units get built and when.
The report points to two forces that affect that pipeline. Two interviewees who work on Santa Monica land use, one public and one private, said some entitled apartment projects went on indefinite hold after voters adopted Measure GS in 2023. Measure GS is a 5.6% real property transfer tax on transactions valued at $8 million or more. RAND says the tax amounts to more than 30% of a typical expected return on a development project. The second force works the other way. A city pilot program now lets market-rate projects meet affordable-housing requirements through in-lieu fees or off-site units, and it has been credited with reviving several stalled projects.
The industry view of the reforms is strong:
"I would rather propose a housing project in Santa Monica than literally any other jurisdiction in the entire state of California."
An experienced land-use attorney said this in an interview for the RAND report. The authors add that they have not tested the reforms' effects with quantitative data.
Reading the comparison cities
A buyer comparing Santa Monica with Beverly Hills, West Hollywood and Culver City can use the RAND report two ways. On retail, the report finds that Santa Monica's downtown tax base lost about a third of its real value, mostly in large spaces on two shopping streets, and that is where the city's $3 million is going. Its housing chapter describes a city that adds new homes slowly, takes longer to approve them than nearby parts of Los Angeles, and has thousands of approved units whose timing depends on permits, coastal review and project finances.
The housing findings bear more directly on what buyers can choose from. Very little new supply has arrived. The 3,296 market-rate units that could add to it were still waiting for building permits as of the October 1 coverage.
FAQ
Does the RAND report include home prices? No. RAND's housing chapter covers production, permits and approval times. It does not include a home-price series or a city-by-city comparison of sale prices.
Is the Promenade really 31% vacant? That was RAND's figure for August 2026, based on 37 retail properties. Downtown Santa Monica Inc. counts 79% of stores as leased. The two numbers measure different things.
How are hotels doing? Santa Monica's hotel occupancy reached 76% in March 2026, the highest of the submarkets RAND studied. Real lodging revenue has declined gradually since fiscal 2022, which the authors say suggests hotels have cut prices to fill rooms. The Daily Press covered the findings.
This post is general information and not legal or tax advice. If Measure GS or coastal permitting could affect a sale or a project you are planning, confirm the details with an attorney or tax professional.
If you own in Santa Monica and want to know how a thin pipeline of new homes affects the value of yours, Johannes Steinbeck will review your property with you, room by room and comp by comp. Request a Home Valuation, and we will start with the buildings that are actually competing with yours.